TFSA vs RRSP Calculator
See which account puts more after-tax money in your pocket at retirement, based on your income and province.
Open both accounts on Wealthsimple
Get a $25 signup bonus with code QJQSMR
Understanding the TFSA vs RRSP choice
The TFSA vs RRSP decision is one of the most consequential choices a Canadian investor makes — and also one of the most misunderstood. Most people frame it as a competition, when in reality the two accounts serve different but complementary purposes. Understanding the mechanics of each account, and how they interact with your specific income and retirement expectations, is the difference between leaving tens of thousands of dollars on the table and maximizing every dollar you invest.
The Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA) uses after-tax dollars for contributions. You don’t get a tax deduction when you contribute, but all investment growth and every withdrawal is completely tax-free — forever. Withdrawals also restore your contribution room the following calendar year, making the TFSA a flexible account you can use throughout your life without penalty.
The Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) works in reverse. Contributions reduce your taxable income in the year you contribute, generating a tax refund. Your investments grow tax-sheltered inside the account, and you pay income tax on withdrawals in retirement. The RRSP essentially lets you borrow from your future self: you defer tax from today’s higher-earning years to retirement’s lower-income years.
How the calculator models your decision
This calculator takes a mathematically rigorous approach to the TFSA vs RRSP comparison. Rather than just showing you the ending balance inside each account, it models the actual after-tax wealth you’d have available in retirement, accounting for the tax refund the RRSP generates today and the tax you’d owe on RRSP withdrawals later.
The TFSA scenario is straightforward: you contribute your chosen amount from after-tax income, it grows at your specified return for your investment horizon, and the ending balance is yours to keep entirely tax-free. No withdrawal tax, no government claim on your growth.
The RRSP scenario is more nuanced. The calculator estimates your current marginal tax rate based on your income and province. Your contribution generates a refund at that marginal rate. Crucially, the calculator assumes you reinvest that refund — which is the mathematically correct comparison. Both your original contribution and the reinvested refund then compound for your investment horizon. At withdrawal, the entire balance is taxed at your estimated retirement rate.
When the TFSA wins
The TFSA comes out ahead when your current marginal tax rate is low relative to your expected retirement tax rate, or when the two rates are roughly equal. If you’re earning $60,000 today and expect similar retirement income, the TFSA and RRSP are mathematically equivalent before considering the refund reinvestment. But if you expect retirement income of $70,000 or more from CPP, OAS, RRSP withdrawals, and other sources, the TFSA’s fully tax-free withdrawals can be significantly more valuable.
The TFSA also wins in scenarios where flexibility matters. Unlike RRSP withdrawals, TFSA withdrawals don’t affect your income for tax purposes — which means they don’t trigger OAS clawbacks, don’t affect income-tested benefits like the GIS, and don’t push you into a higher tax bracket in retirement.
Young Canadians just starting their careers typically benefit most from the TFSA. If you’re earning $50,000–$65,000 early in your career and expect your income to rise significantly, contributing to the TFSA now means you’re sheltering money at a lower rate today, saving your RRSP room for years when contributions generate larger refunds.
When the RRSP wins
The RRSP comes out ahead when there’s a meaningful gap between your current marginal tax rate and your expected retirement tax rate — specifically when you’ll pay less tax at withdrawal than you avoided at contribution. If you’re earning $120,000 today (putting you in a 43% combined federal-provincial bracket in Ontario) and expect retirement income of $70,000 (pushing you into the 26% bracket), the RRSP’s deduction at 43% far exceeds the tax owed on withdrawal at 26%.
High-income professionals in their peak earning years — doctors, lawyers, engineers, executives earning $150,000–$250,000 — are typically the biggest RRSP beneficiaries. At these income levels, the federal-provincial combined marginal rate can reach 50–54%. If retirement income falls to $80,000–$100,000, the 10–20% rate differential represents an enormous advantage on every dollar contributed.
The case for using both accounts
The optimal strategy for many Canadians isn’t choosing one account over the other — it’s using both strategically to minimize lifetime tax paid on investment growth. A common recommended sequence is: TFSA first (to build an emergency fund and flexible savings), then FHSA if you’re a first-time buyer, then RRSP for the tax deduction advantage, and then back to the TFSA once RRSP is maximized.
Using the RRSP refund to fund TFSA contributions is a particularly powerful strategy. If you contribute $10,000 to an RRSP and receive a $4,000 tax refund (40% marginal rate), putting that refund into your TFSA gives you $14,000 growing tax-sheltered from a $10,000 after-tax outlay. Over decades, this can add tens of thousands of dollars to your retirement wealth.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I contribute to both a TFSA and RRSP in the same year?
Yes — there is no rule preventing you from contributing to both in the same year. Your TFSA contribution limit (2025: up to $7,000 per year, $102,000 cumulative for those eligible since 2009) and your RRSP contribution room (18% of prior year earned income, up to $32,490 for 2025) are completely independent limits. Many Canadians contribute to both simultaneously, prioritizing the allocation based on their current income and retirement projections.
What happens to RRSP room I don’t use?
Unused RRSP contribution room carries forward indefinitely. If you’ve never contributed to an RRSP and have been earning income since you were 18, you may have accumulated significant contribution room. You can check your exact available room on your CRA My Account portal or on your most recent Notice of Assessment. This accumulated room can be used all at once in a high-income year to generate a large tax refund.
Does TFSA income affect government benefits like OAS?
No — TFSA withdrawals are not counted as income for any government purpose. This means TFSA income doesn’t affect OAS clawback thresholds (the 2025 clawback begins at $90,997 in net income), doesn’t affect Guaranteed Income Supplement (GIS) eligibility, and doesn’t push you into a higher federal or provincial tax bracket. For retirees with significant RRSP/RRIF income, the TFSA is particularly valuable as a source of supplemental income that doesn’t trigger clawbacks.
Should I withdraw from RRSP before converting to RRIF at 71?
Strategically withdrawing from your RRSP before converting to a RRIF at age 71 — commonly called RRSP meltdown — can reduce your lifetime tax burden if done carefully. The strategy involves withdrawing in lower-income years (typically between retirement and age 65–71 when CPP, OAS, and other income hasn’t fully begun) at a lower marginal rate than you would face under mandatory RRIF withdrawals later. This is a complex strategy best discussed with a financial advisor or tax professional.
Related Calculators
These free tools help you build a complete picture of your Canadian investment strategy:
- Compound Interest Calculator — See what your RRSP refund or TFSA contributions can grow to over time with compound interest.
- RRSP Contribution Calculator — Calculate your exact 2025 RRSP room and estimate your tax refund at your marginal rate.
- FHSA Contribution Calculator — Track your First Home Savings Account room and project your balance at purchase.
- Transfer Bonus Calculator — See how much cash you earn when you transfer existing accounts to Wealthsimple.
- Bonus Stack Calculator — Add up every Wealthsimple bonus you qualify for before opening your account.