Home / ETF / ETF vs Mutual Fund Canada 2026: Which Is Better for Investors?

ETF vs Mutual Fund Canada 2026: Which Is Better for Investors?

Juveria T., founder and editor of GrowSimple

By Juveria T.

Open your Wealthsimple account today and get your free bonus

TL;DR

ETFs (Exchange-Traded Funds) and mutual funds both pool investor money into a diversified portfolio, but ETFs are almost always the better choice for self-directed Canadian investors. ETFs have dramatically lower fees (0.10–0.25% MER vs 1.5–2.5% for actively managed mutual funds), greater transparency, and better tax efficiency. The main exception: if you can only access investments through an employer group plan or need the convenience of automatic monthly mutual fund contributions without any investing knowledge.

What Is an ETF?

An Exchange-Traded Fund (ETF) is a fund that holds a collection of securities (stocks, bonds, or other assets) and trades on a stock exchange like a regular share. Most ETFs are passively managed — they track a specific index (like the S&P 500 or the TSX Composite) and simply hold the securities in that index, rather than trying to pick winners.

Key ETF characteristics:

  • Trades on stock exchanges (TSX, NYSE, etc.) throughout the day at market prices
  • Price fluctuates in real time during market hours
  • Typically passively managed (index tracking)
  • Very low MERs: 0.06–0.25% for most broad-market ETFs
  • Highly transparent (daily disclosure of all holdings)
  • Minimum purchase: price of 1 unit (typically $15–$150)

What Is a Mutual Fund?

A mutual fund is an investment fund managed by a professional portfolio manager. Unlike ETFs, mutual funds price only once per day (at the end of trading), and you buy and sell directly through the fund company or your bank, not through a stock exchange. Most Canadian mutual funds are actively managed — the portfolio manager makes decisions about which securities to buy and sell.

Key mutual fund characteristics:

  • Priced once per day after market close (NAV)
  • Bought/sold directly through the fund company or financial institution
  • Usually actively managed (portfolio manager making picks)
  • High MERs: 1.5–2.5% for actively managed Canadian mutual funds
  • Less transparent (holdings typically disclosed quarterly)
  • Can set up automatic monthly contributions of any amount

ETF vs Mutual Fund: Complete Side-by-Side Comparison

FeatureETFMutual Fund
How you buy/sellThrough a brokerage (e.g., Wealthsimple Trade)Through the fund company or bank
PricingReal-time during market hoursOnce daily (end of day NAV)
Typical management stylePassive (index-tracking)Active (portfolio manager decisions)
Average MER in Canada0.06–0.25%1.5–2.5%
TransparencyDaily holdings disclosureQuarterly holdings disclosure
Minimum investmentPrice of 1 unitOften $500–$1,000 minimum; sometimes $25/month
Automatic contributionsDepends on brokerageUsually yes, flexible dollar amounts
Tax efficiencyHigher (lower portfolio turnover)Lower (active trading generates taxable events)
AccessRequires brokerage accountAvailable directly through banks and advisors
Advice includedNoSometimes (through advisor)

The Fee Gap: Why It Matters So Much

The most critical difference between ETFs and mutual funds is fees. The average Canadian actively managed equity mutual fund charges approximately 2.0–2.5% MER per year. A comparable broad-market ETF charges 0.10–0.25%. This gap compounds dramatically over time.

Example: $100,000 invested over 30 years at 7% gross return:

ProductAnnual FeeNet ReturnValue After 30 YearsLost to Fees
Index ETF (XEQT)0.20%6.80%~$723,000~$38,000
Typical mutual fund2.00%5.00%~$432,000~$329,000
Expensive mutual fund2.50%4.50%~$374,000~$387,000

The investor in a typical mutual fund ends up with 40% less wealth than the ETF investor — with the same starting amount, same contributions, and same underlying market return. The only difference is the fee. Understanding how compound interest works against you when fees are high is one of the most valuable insights in personal finance. Run your own numbers with our mutual fund fee calculator to see exactly what your current MER is costing you.

Do Actively Managed Mutual Funds Beat ETFs?

The empirical evidence is clear and consistent: most actively managed mutual funds underperform their benchmark index over the long term, after fees.

SPIVA Canada data (2024 report):

  • Over a 5-year period, approximately 82% of Canadian equity funds underperformed the S&P/TSX Composite Index
  • Over a 10-year period, approximately 90% of Canadian equity funds underperformed
  • Over a 15-year period, approximately 92% of Canadian equity funds underperformed

The longer the time period, the worse active management looks versus passive index ETFs. This is not because fund managers are bad at their jobs — it’s because the fees they charge make it mathematically difficult to outperform an index ETF over the long term.

When Might Mutual Funds Still Make Sense?

Despite the fee disadvantage, there are specific scenarios where mutual funds remain appropriate:

1. Employer Group Plans (DC Pension, Group RRSP)

Many employer-sponsored savings plans (Defined Contribution pensions, group RRSPs) offer only mutual funds. If your employer offers a matching contribution, taking advantage of that match — even in a mutual fund — is almost always worth it. An employer match of 50% or 100% on your contribution outweighs the fee disadvantage.

2. Investors Who Won’t DIY

For some people, the convenience of walking into a bank, signing up for a managed mutual fund portfolio, and never thinking about it again is worth the extra cost. An investor who pays 2% per year in a mutual fund and actually invests will often end up better off than an investor who plans to buy ETFs but keeps procrastinating and leaves money in a savings account.

3. Specific Mandate Funds

Some mutual funds offer exposure to asset classes or strategies that don’t have ETF equivalents (certain private credit funds, alternatives, etc.). For specialized mandates, mutual funds may be the only vehicle available.

Index Mutual Funds: A Middle Ground

It’s worth noting that not all mutual funds are actively managed. Index mutual funds track a market index (like ETFs do) but are structured as traditional mutual funds rather than exchange-traded products. In Canada, the most well-known index mutual funds are:

  • TD e-Series Funds: Very popular, low-MER index funds (0.20–0.35%) available directly through TD Bank. No brokerage required.
  • Tangerine Core Portfolios: Balanced index portfolios at approximately 1.07% MER (higher than ETFs, but lower than most active funds).

Index mutual funds are a reasonable middle ground for investors who can’t access ETFs or prefer automatic monthly contributions in flexible dollar amounts. Their fees are still higher than equivalent ETFs, but dramatically lower than actively managed funds.

How to Switch from Mutual Funds to ETFs

If you’re currently holding actively managed mutual funds at your bank and want to switch to lower-cost ETFs, the process is:

  1. Open a self-directed brokerage account (e.g., Wealthsimple Trade, Questrade)
  2. Open the appropriate registered accounts (TFSA, RRSP) that match your current accounts
  3. Sell your mutual funds (check for any deferred sales charge — DSC — which some older mutual funds charge for early redemption)
  4. Transfer the cash to your new brokerage account via bank transfer
  5. Buy your chosen ETF(s) — for a one-fund approach, XEQT or XGRO are the most popular

Important: If you’re moving registered accounts (TFSA, RRSP), request a direct transfer from your bank to your new brokerage rather than withdrawing and re-depositing. A direct TFSA transfer doesn’t count as a withdrawal, preserving your contribution room. See our guide on Wealthsimple withdrawals for more context on how account transfers work.

The Simplest ETF Alternative to a Canadian Mutual Fund

If you’re currently in a balanced or growth mutual fund, the ETF equivalent is usually one of the all-in-one iShares or Vanguard funds:

If your mutual fund is…ETF equivalentMER saving (approximate)
Balanced (50/50 stock/bond)XBAL or VBAL~1.8% per year
Growth (75/25 stock/bond)XGRO or VGRO~1.8% per year
Equity (100% stocks)XEQT or VEQT~1.8% per year

Frequently Asked Questions

Are ETFs better than mutual funds in Canada?

For most self-directed investors: yes. ETFs have dramatically lower fees (0.10-0.25% vs 1.5-2.5%), greater transparency, and better long-term performance records after fees. Over 90% of actively managed Canadian equity mutual funds underperform a comparable index ETF over 15-year periods (SPIVA data).

What is the difference between an ETF and a mutual fund?

ETFs trade on stock exchanges like shares, price in real time, are usually passively managed, and have low fees. Mutual funds price once daily, are bought directly through fund companies or banks, are usually actively managed, and charge higher fees. Both pool investor money into a diversified portfolio.

Can I replace my mutual fund with an ETF?

Yes. Sell your mutual fund (check for DSC fees on older funds), transfer the cash to a self-directed brokerage like Wealthsimple Trade, and buy an equivalent ETF. For a one-fund approach, XEQT (100% equity) or XGRO (80/20) are the most popular replacements for Canadian equity or balanced mutual funds.

Are ETFs riskier than mutual funds?

ETFs and mutual funds carry similar market risk for equivalent underlying assets. A global equity ETF and a global equity mutual fund both rise and fall with global stock markets. The key difference is not risk but cost, transparency, and management approach, not the fund structure itself.

Why do banks in Canada still sell expensive mutual funds?

Banks earn significantly more revenue from mutual funds (1.5-2.5% MER) than from ETFs. A portion of the MER is paid to advisors as a trailing commission, incentivizing them to recommend mutual funds over lower-cost alternatives. This is a well-documented conflict of interest in Canadian financial services.

Open your Wealthsimple account today and get your free bonus

Juveria T., founder and editor of GrowSimple

Juveria is a financial content writer at GrowSimple.ca, passionate about helping Canadians understand money and investing. She simplifies complex financial topics — from ETFs and TFSAs to platforms like Wealthsimple — through clear, research-based articles designed for everyday investors.

Juveria T.