Home / Investing Basics / 10 Biggest Investing Mistakes Canadians Make (And How to Avoid Them)

10 Biggest Investing Mistakes Canadians Make (And How to Avoid Them)

Juveria T., founder and editor of GrowSimple

By Juveria T.

Open your Wealthsimple account today and get your free bonus

Investing is simple in theory but hard in practice — not because markets are unpredictable, but because human psychology works against us at every turn. The most costly investing mistakes aren’t complex errors made by sophisticated traders; they’re basic behavioral and structural mistakes made by everyday Canadians. Avoiding these 10 mistakes alone could add hundreds of thousands of dollars to your lifetime investment returns.

Mistake 1: Not Investing at All (Keeping Everything in Cash)

The most expensive investing mistake is waiting to invest. Many Canadians leave tens of thousands of dollars in a chequing account or low-rate savings account for years while “getting comfortable” with investing. At 2–3% inflation, cash loses 1–2% of real purchasing power every year. The cost of a 5-year delay starting at age 30 — compared to investing immediately in a diversified ETF — is approximately $50,000–$100,000 in terminal wealth at age 65 (for a $500/month saver at 7% return).

Fix: Open a TFSA at Wealthsimple (code QJQSMR) today. Buy one all-in-one ETF like XEQT. Start with any amount. The best time to invest was 10 years ago; the second best time is today.

Mistake 2: Paying Too Much in Fees

The average Canadian mutual fund charges 2–2.5% in MER (Management Expense Ratio) annually. A comparable all-in-one ETF charges 0.20%. On a $200,000 portfolio over 25 years at 7% gross return:

ProductAnnual FeePortfolio Value After 25 YearsFees Paid
Typical bank mutual fund2.3% MER~$780,000~$390,000 in fees
All-in-one ETF (XEQT)0.20% MER~$1,120,000~$47,000 in fees
Difference+$340,000-$343,000 in fees

Fix: Switch from bank mutual funds to low-cost ETFs. For a comparison of why ETFs beat mutual funds, see our ETF vs Mutual Fund Canada guide.

Mistake 3: Panic Selling During Market Crashes

The most common and costly behavioral mistake: selling investments when markets fall, locking in losses, then reinvesting after the recovery at higher prices. Research shows that individual investors who panic sell during downturns underperform a buy-and-hold investor by 1.5–3% per year on average. In a 2022-style 14% correction, selling XEQT and buying back 6 months later at recovery would have cost approximately 12–18% in realized losses plus missed recovery gains.

Fix: Build an investment policy statement before investing that defines your plan for market downturns (“I will not sell during any correction under 30%”). Automate contributions so you buy more when markets fall. See our guide on what to do during a stock market crash in Canada.

Mistake 4: Ignoring Registered Accounts (TFSA and RRSP)

Investing in a non-registered account before maxing your TFSA is one of the most common beginner errors. Every dollar of investment growth inside a TFSA is permanently tax-free. Outside a TFSA, you pay tax on dividends annually and capital gains tax when you sell. Over 30 years, the tax drag on a non-registered portfolio vs a TFSA can consume 15–25% of terminal wealth.

Fix: Always fill TFSA first ($7,000/year in 2026), then RRSP, then non-registered. Open a TFSA at Wealthsimple (code QJQSMR) if you don’t have one. For the TFSA vs RRSP priority decision, see our TFSA vs RRSP guide.

Mistake 5: Checking Your Portfolio Too Often

Research consistently shows that investors who check their portfolios daily make worse decisions than those who check monthly or annually. Daily checking creates emotional attachment to short-term fluctuations, increasing the probability of panic selling, unnecessary rebalancing, and impulsive changes. Portfolio performance is directly correlated with checking frequency — the less often you look, the better your long-term behavior.

Fix: Set a calendar reminder to review your portfolio quarterly or annually. Automate contributions so the investing happens without requiring you to log in each time.

Mistake 6: Trying to Time the Market

“I’ll wait until markets drop before investing” is one of the most expensive phrases in investing. Research shows that missing just the 10 best trading days in a 20-year period reduces total returns by approximately 50%. Since the 10 best days typically occur during the most volatile periods (often immediately following crashes), investors who are out of the market during corrections often miss the recovery entirely.

Fix: Invest as soon as you have funds available. If anxiety prevents lump-sum investing, use dollar-cost averaging over 6–12 months. For the lump sum vs DCA evidence, see our lump sum investing guide.

Mistake 7: Over-Diversifying (Too Many ETFs)

Counter-intuitively, many beginners “improve” their portfolios by adding more ETFs until they have 8–12 funds with significant overlapping holdings. Holding XIC (Canadian), XEQT (which already includes Canada), plus several sector ETFs and a gold ETF creates a complex, expensive portfolio that often underperforms a single XEQT holding.

Fix: For most Canadians, one all-in-one ETF (XEQT or XGRO) in a TFSA/RRSP is the optimal portfolio. Adding complexity rarely adds returns; it almost always adds cost and behavioral risk.

Mistake 8: Letting TFSA Room Accumulate Unused

Every year you leave TFSA contribution room unused is a year of tax-free compounding permanently lost. Unlike RRSP room (which carries forward and can be used later at higher income), unused TFSA room simply means less tax-free compounding over your lifetime. A Canadian who didn’t contribute to their TFSA from 2018–2025 missed 8 years of tax-free growth on up to $56,500 in contribution room.

Mistake 9: Not Reinvesting Dividends

Receiving ETF distributions as cash and leaving them sitting rather than reinvesting dramatically reduces long-term returns. Over 30 years, reinvesting dividends vs taking them as cash can nearly double your terminal portfolio value through compound growth. Most brokerages offer automatic DRIP (Dividend Reinvestment Plans). For how DRIP works, see our ETF DRIP Canada guide.

Mistake 10: Not Having an Emergency Fund Before Investing

Investing without a 3–6 month emergency fund in a HISA means any unexpected expense (job loss, car repair, medical) forces you to sell investments — potentially at a loss and in a down market. The emergency fund’s purpose is precisely to prevent forced selling. Build 3–6 months of expenses in a HISA first, then invest the rest. See our emergency fund Canada guide.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the biggest investing mistake Canadians make?

The most costly mistake is not investing at all — keeping everything in cash or low-rate savings while ‘waiting for the right time.’ The second most costly is paying excessive fees in bank mutual funds (2-2.5% MER) when low-cost ETFs are available at 0.20% MER. These two mistakes alone cost most Canadians hundreds of thousands of dollars in lifetime wealth.

How do I avoid panic selling during a stock market crash?

Have a written investment plan before markets drop. Define in advance the conditions under which you will sell (ideally: never, unless your financial situation changes fundamentally). Automate contributions so you continue buying during crashes. Reduce portfolio checking to quarterly. Hold a 3-6 month emergency fund so you never need to sell investments to cover expenses.

Is it a mistake to invest without maxing my TFSA?

Yes. Any investment growth in a non-registered account is taxed annually (dividends) and on sale (capital gains). The exact same growth inside a TFSA is permanently tax-free. Always fill your TFSA ($7,000/year in 2026) before investing in a non-registered account. RRSP comes second if your income is above 35% marginal rate.

Is it a mistake to have too many ETFs?

Yes, often. Many beginners add ETFs thinking more diversification is better. But XEQT already holds 9,000+ stocks in 50+ countries. Adding more ETFs creates overlap, complexity, and often higher total costs without improving returns. For most Canadians, 1-3 ETFs is the optimal portfolio. One all-in-one ETF like XEQT is sufficient.

What should a beginner investor in Canada do to avoid mistakes?

Five key actions: (1) Open a TFSA at Wealthsimple (code QJQSMR) and buy a single all-in-one ETF. (2) Automate monthly contributions. (3) Build a 3-6 month emergency fund first. (4) Never check your portfolio more than monthly. (5) Commit in writing to not selling during corrections. These five habits outperform most sophisticated strategies.

Open your Wealthsimple account today and get your free bonus

Juveria T., founder and editor of GrowSimple

Juveria is a financial content writer at GrowSimple.ca, passionate about helping Canadians understand money and investing. She simplifies complex financial topics — from ETFs and TFSAs to platforms like Wealthsimple — through clear, research-based articles designed for everyday investors.

Juveria T.